CACINA CACINA Catholic Apostolic Church in North America

Prayer Requests Donations

  • Home
  • About Us
    • A Church Where All Are Welcome
    • Affiliations
    • Church Governance
      • Apostolic Succession
        • Apostolic Succession for Michael Theogene, OSB
        • Apostolic Succession for Antony F. Santore, FCR
        • Apostolic Succession for Francisco J. A. Betancourt, FCR
        • Apostolic Succession for Ronald Wilbert Stephens
        • Apostolic Succession for Willard E. Schultz
        • Apostolic Succession for Anthony Green, FCR
        • Apostolic Succession for Monica Kennedy
        • Apostolic Succession of Michael Ellis, NFCR
      • Constitution and Code of Canons
    • Independent Catholicism
    • Pastoral Messages
    • Religious Communities
      • Benedictines of Peace and Justice
      • Franciscan Order of Reconciliation
    • In Memorium
      • Fr. Larry Hansen
      • Fr. Paul Julius Pfadenhauer
      • Joseph H. Reynolds
      • James Marsh, OSB
      • Raymond Francis Kelly, OSB-Cistercian
      • Mother Anne Stewart
      • Fr. Azzali
  • Parishes & Missions
    • Our Churches
      • St. Andrew the Apostle Parish
      • St. Benedict Parish
      • St. Charles of Brazil Parish
      • St. John of God Parish
      • St. Martin of Tours Mission Parish
    • Our Missions
      • Holy Innocents Oratory
      • Incarnation Catholic Community Mission
      • Julian of Norwich Mission
      • Mission of the Holy Archangels
      • St. Anne Mission
      • St. Jude Oratory
      • Sts. Luke and Mary Magdalene Oratory
    • Live Stream Masses
  • Vocation
    • Service through Ordination in CACINA
    • Discernment
    • Deacon or Priest?
    • How long does it take?
  • Saint Charles of Brazil Institute
  • History of CACINA
    • Bishop Carlos Duarte-Costa
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Divine Office

Pastoral Letter on Murder of Renee Nicole Good

Pastoral Letter from the CACINA College of Bishops on the Murder of Renee Nicole Good

January 10, 2026

 

Dear Sisters and Brothers in Christ,

 

At the Jordan River, as Jesus entered the waters of baptism, Matthew tells us

that the heavens opened and a voice declared: “This is my beloved Son, with

whom I am well pleased.” (Matthew 3:17). In this moment, God affirmed not

only Jesus’s identity but also the divine truth that every human life is precious,

beloved, and made in the image of the Creator (cf. Genesis 1:27). Baptism

reveals a God who stands with humanity—especially with those who suffer,

those who are overlooked, and those who bear the weight of injustice.

It is from this place of faith and conviction that we, the College of Bishops of

The Catholic Apostolic Church in North America, write to you with grief,

compassion, and righteous anger.

 

Our hearts are heavy as we mourn the killing of Renee Nicole Good, a 37-

year-old mother, poet, and beloved member of her community who was shot

by an ICE agent during an enforcement operation in Minneapolis. We lament

her death and the many wounds that follow: wounds to her children, to her

family, to her friends, and to all who must watch the traumatic images of her

final moments circulate across our screens and public discourse.

 

We assure Renee’s children and family of our prayers and our solidarity. We

mourn alongside them. The Lord is near to the brokenhearted, the psalmist

tells us, “and saves those crushed in spirit.” (Psalm 34:18). Our Church

carries their sorrow in its own heart.

 

The killing of Renee Nicole Good unfolds within a broader context that we

must not ignore. We live in a time when national rhetoric, immigration policy,

and political strategy have inflamed hostility, normalized fear, and justified

acts of aggression against the most vulnerable. Forces at the highest levels of

our federal government—both past and present—continue to exploit division

as a tool of power. As shepherds of the Church, we cannot remain silent when

such forces threaten the dignity God has bestowed upon every person.

 

The Gospel compels us to name injustice when it is before us. The prophets

cried out in times of violence; Jesus wept over the city; the early Church

proclaimed good news to the poor, release to the captive, and liberty to the

oppressed (cf. Luke 4:18). There is, therefore, a place for righteous anger—

not anger born of hatred or vengeance, but anger rooted in love for the

vulnerable and in fidelity to the God of justice. Such anger refuses to treat

human beings as expendable or disposable. It refuses to accept violence

against the marginalized as the cost of national order.

 

Yet our anger must always be accompanied by compassion. The One who

overturned the tables in the Temple is the same One who forgave his

persecutors from the cross. The Gospel calls us to a justice that does not

dehumanize even those with whom we vehemently disagree. While we

advocate for transparency, accountability, and reform within our civil

structures, we must also uphold the dignity of all persons—including those

whose actions we condemn.

 

As your bishops, we call upon the faithful of our Church to respond to this

moment with the fullness of Christian discipleship:

 

1. To pray without ceasing—for Renee Nicole Good’s family, for her

children, and for all who mourn;

2. To stand boldly for justice, including due process of law—so that no

person is treated as less than beloved in the eyes of God;

3. To embody compassion in our communities—offering welcome,

advocacy, and accompaniment to those who live in fear;

4. To resist every form of dehumanization—whether in speech, policy, or

practice;

5. To labor for peace—the peace that rests not on force, but on

reconciliation and human dignity.

 

We conclude with the words of St. Paul, who reminded the Church in

Corinth that “If one member suffers, all suffer together.” (1 Corinthians

12:26). May we, as the Body of Christ, suffer together with Renee’s family,

advocate together for justice, and hope together for a world where every

person—immigrant and citizen, neighbor and stranger—is treated as beloved

in the sight of God.

 

May the Holy Spirit, who descended upon Jesus at the Jordan, bestow upon

us courage for the work of justice, tenderness for the work of healing, and

steadfastness for the work of peace.

 

In Christ’s abiding love,

The College of Bishops

The Catholic Apostolic Church in North Americ

Pastoral Letter on Political Violence

The CACINA College of Bishops unanimously endorses the following pastoral letter from Bishop Tony Green, issued on September 15, 2025, for dissemination to the National Church.

_______________________________________________

Dear St. John of God Parishioners and Friends:


I feel compelled to write to you in light of the troubling rise in political violence in our nation. Most recently, 
the assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk has unleashed a torrent of vitriolic and hateful rhetoric. 
As Christians, we are called to resist anger and vengeance, and instead lean into our faith, walking in the way of 
Christ. When we answer violence with violence, or hatred with hatred, we only deepen the divisions and risk 
even greater harm.


It grieves me that some political leaders choose to exploit these tragedies by blaming their rivals, rather than 
speaking words that promote unity, discourage violence, and seek peace. I encourage you to raise your voices 
with your elected representatives—not in condemnation, but in the service of the common good, urging them to 
promote peace, justice, and policies that protect the dignity of all people.


I am fully aware that many of us did not share Mr. Kirk’s views, and that some of his ideas caused real harm. 
Yet he, like all of us, had the right to speak freely. He did not deserve to be murdered for his speech, no matter 
how strongly we may have disagreed with him. Our faith reminds us that every person bears the image of God, 
even those with whom we profoundly disagree.


Jesus himself commanded us to love our enemies and pray for those who persecute us. From the cross he 
prayed, “Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do.” His words remain a summons to us: to pray, to 
forgive, and to stand for peace even in the face of violence.


We also remember the heartbreaking deaths of Minnesota State Lawmaker Melissa Hortman and her husband 
Mark, who were assassinated only months ago, as well as the children killed at Annunciation Catholic School. 
Each of these tragedies is a stark reminder of the urgent need for our leaders to address gun violence with 
courage and wisdom.


I urge you to keep all of these victims, their families, and even the perpetrators of these crimes in your prayers. 
Pray for their healing, their repentance, and for God’s peace to break into the brokenness of our world.


Finally, I ask you to resist the temptation to lash out on social media or in conversations in ways that deepen our 
political divides. Instead, let us bear witness to our faith by affirming the truth that every person is created in the 
image and likeness of God and is deserving of dignity and respect.


May Christ, the Prince of Peace, guide our hearts and our words, that we may be instruments of reconciliation in 
a time of discord.


In Christ’s peace,
Bishop Tony Green, FCR

Pastoral Letter from College of Bishops in Support of Bishop Mariann Edgar Budde of the Episcopal Church

CACINA College of Bishops Pastoral Letter in Support of Bishop Mariann Edgar Budde of the Episcopal Church.

Michael Ellis Consecrated Bishop in CACINA

On Saturday, October 26th – 2024 – Michael Ellis, NFCR, was ordained a Bishop in the Catholic Apostolic Church in North America (CACINA). The service was held at the CACINA Parish of St. John of God in Schenectady, New York. Bishop Anthony Green, FCR, Auxiliary Bishop in the Diocese of Little Portion, was the principal consecrator with CACINA’s Presiding Bishop Michael Theogene, OSB, and Bishop Monica Kennedy as Co-consecrators. Many of Bishop Ellis’ family friends and colleagues were in attendance.  Also, clergy from Protestant faith traditions attended, including Pastor Katelyn Bradwell of Eastern Parkway United Methodist Church where St. John of God Parish nests.

The following day, on Sunday, October 27th, Bishop Francisco Betancourt, FCR, who has been the Ordinary of the Diocese of Little Portion for more than 20 years, moved to the position of Bishop Emeritus and passed the crozier of the Ordinary to Bishop Green, with Bishop Ellis taking the position of Auxiliary Bishop.

The Catholic Apostolic Church in North America has a rich history and is proud to have sustained a lineage of direct apostolic lines to Bishop Carlos Duarte Costa, who is also known as St. Charles of Brazil. The Igreja Católica Apostólica Brasileira (ICAB), in English The Brazilian Catholic Apostolic Church, canonized Costa on July 4, 1970, and gave him the title "São Carlos do Brasil" - Saint Charles of Brazil.

CACINA has carried on Dom Carlos’ theological vision of liberation theology. At its core, his theology was incarnational - not just God with us, but God as one of us.  Dom Carlos understood that a Christian theology of liberation is tasked with engaging the world from the faith perspective of a Christ who situates himself in solidarity with those whom society has marginalized. In God’s preferential option for the poor, the messianic community is identified and formed, and the church is made visible.

Carlos Duarte Costa centered his devotional life in the Catholic intellectual tradition’s dialogue between fides and praxis.  In his writing (which is not voluminous), and especially in his embrace of faithful Christian discipleship as a countercultural call to radical identification with the poor, we observe the foundation of much that would inform later theologians, giving shape to a mature theology of liberation. Almost alone at the time, he was also an environmentalist bishop, steadfastly maintaining that the world’s resources must be held not in private ownership but in sacred trust for the well-being of all creation.

Bishop Michael Ellis joins the College of Bishops of CACINA as it celebrates its 75th year of ministry as a national Catholic Church this year. Bishop Ellis joins with the CACINA College of Bishops to oversee thirteen parishes and missions through the United States, most of which are in the northeast. Bishop Ellis comes to the bishop role with more than thirty years of work as a psychotherapist in private practice, and he will continue his vocational ministry in hospice chaplaincy.

 

College of Bishops Statement on the Roman Catholic "Dignitas Infinita"

Statement on Trans People

The College of Bishops issued a Pastoral Statement in response to the  Roman Catholic Declaration of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith "Dignitas Infinita" on Human Dignity.

 

More Articles …

  1. College of Bishops Statement on the Israel-Hamas Conflict
  2. College of Bishops Statement on School Shooting in Tennessee
  3. CACINA's College of Bishops Elects new Presiding Bishop
  4. Father Michael Ellis Elected CACINA Chancellor
Page 1 of 15
  • Start
  • Prev
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • Next
  • End

 

        6230 NE 184th Terrace
        Williston, Florida 32696
        Phone: 352-405-0121

   Email:  info@cacina.org

Resources

  • Calendar
  • Donations
  • News
  • Photo Gallery
  • Prayer Requests

  facebook2

Copyright  2024 CACINA. All Rights Reserved